Showing posts with label aperture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label aperture. Show all posts

Thursday, January 5, 2012

More On Aperture and DOF

This is a follow up to my recent post about the effect of aperture on the look of a portrait.

There, I mentioned that changing focal length would not affect the depth of field if the camera was moved to maintain the size of the subject in the frame. I didn't have any images prepared then to demonstrate this at the time. I got a chance to create those images last night and present them here. Click on each image to load a larger version that will be easier to study.

 Above we see three photos that were taken with 135mm, 85mm, and 35mm lenses all set to f/2.8. The camera was moved closer with the 85 and even closer with the 35 to make the mannequin head be about the same size in each. If you look closely you will see that the depth of field is about the same in each. The perspective is different in each because the camera was moved (not because of the lens change).

Many photographers go for a lens in the 85 to 105mm (full 35mm frame) range for portraits because they put you at a distance from your subject that gives a nice drawing to the face with pleasing relationship between the features on the face and head (nose, mouth, eyes, ears). If working with a smaller sensor camera look for lenses with similar angles of view for that format (such as 50-65mm on cameras with a 1.5 or 1.6x multiplier).


In the second set of photos everything is the same as the first set, except that the aperture was set to f/22. Again, you can see that the depth of field remains the same, even though various focal length lenses were used (135, 85, and 35).

You may also be surprised to see that the face looks the thinnest in the image taken with the wide angle lens. This is what happens when you move in close. With any lens the objects closest to the camera appear larger than objects further away. When in so close with a short lens the nose is relatively closer to the lens than the cheeks, eyes, and ears. So they fall away and look smaller. When you move back with the longer lens the nose, eyes, and ears are all relatively closer to each other than to the lens, so the face flattens out and they all appear at a similar size. This is due to the camera to subject distance, not the lens, even though this is often erroneously called "telephoto compression." See the fourth set below for more about that.


In this third set of photos the camera remained stationary. The top image was taken with an 85mm, the middle is 135mm, and the bottom is 35mm. Here we can see that the size of the mannequin head is very different between the images and the depth of field changes drastically between because of the difference in magnification from each lens (all set to f/2.8)


In this final group we again have images taken with the 135mm, 85mm, and 35mm lenses, this time all set to f/5.6. As in the third set, the camera remained stationary and the lenses were changed.

In these last two sets of images you should be able to see that the perspective remained the same even though the lenses were changed. The relationship between the head and the background is the same in each. If you cropped in on the 3rd image in this set the perspective would match the 1st image in this set. But the depth of field is different. Remember that when the camera to subject distance is set and the lens is changed the perspective of the area of the image that is common to each image is the same. The camera to lens distance determines the perspective. The focal length determines what fits into that frame.


One of my favorite Ansel Adams quotes is "good photography is about knowing where to stand." I think that many people misunderstand this quote. They might associate it with Jim Richardson's quote "if you want to be a better photographer, stand in front of more interesting stuff."  But what I believe Ansel meant was that you need to find the location to set up the camera that gives you the perspective (relationship between items in the scene) that you want, and then you select a lens focal length that fills the frame the way you want. Too often people pick the lens first.

I really don't like the mantra of "zoom with your feet." Zooming implies making the scene smaller or larger while maintaining the perspective by changing focal length without moving. If you move your feet the perspective changes. So you CANNOT zoom with your feet. I'm not saying it is a bad exercise to select one prime lens and learn how to use it by moving around. If you want to make good and interesting photos, do find your location by moving your feet, but then select the appropriate lens to fill the frame of your camera. Maybe the frame should be "move your butt!" And a zoom lens is the perfect lens for this, as you can frame exactly as you want. Zoom lenses got a bad reputation in the 1970s when the quality wasn't nearly as good as prime lenses. Zoom lens design has come a long way since then and today's zooms come very close to the quality of prime lenses. That said, I often use prime lenses instead of my zooms, but this is primarily because of the weight of a good zoom. The primes are easier on my shoulder, elbow and wrist.

One more thing. Something that I learned during the exercise of preparing this article is that it really is difficult to manually focus a wide angle lens. I've always heard that short lenses were more difficult to focus, but it reallyshowed here. The following set of images were taken with the same camera/lens (35mm at f/2.0) combination. A was manually focused through the viewfinder. B was manually focused using Live View at 10x, and C was autofocused. Maybe autofocus isn't such a bad idea....



Tuesday, May 3, 2011

When does 8-and-1/2 equal 9.5?

View camera lens set to f/8+1/2
I've noticed some confusion amongst photographers when talking about aperture settings. It usually happens when a new photographer is talking with an "old timer" about studio settings and using a flash meter. The discussion often goes something like this...

OT: Set the camera to 8-and-1/2
NB: (thinking to self) Hmm, my options are f/8, f/9, f/10, and f/11 (1/3 stop increments). I'll set it to f/9.
OT: Looks like we're slightly overerexposed. Are you really at 8-and-1/2?
NB: I don't see an 8.5, should I be at f/8 or f/9?
OT: 9? Where did that come from? I want it set halfway between 8 and 11.
NB: OK, I can set the camera to give me 1/2 stop increments. But then I'm at F/9.5. Is that what you want?
OT: Yes
NB: Then why did you ask for 8.5?
OT: I didn't ask for 8.5, I asked for 8-and-1/2
NB: Isn't 8-and-1/2 equal to 8.5?
OT: No, 8-and-1/2 is equal to 9.5.

And they go back and forth for an hour or so.

Canon FD lens set to f/8+1/2
The confusion stems from old film cameras where we had full stop markings on the lens. And on many lenses you could kind of cheat the aperture ring to sit somewhere between two stop markings*. So you could have 1.4, 2.0, 2.8, 4, 5.6, 8, 11, 16, 22. And in between them you had 1.4-and-a-half,2-and-a-half, 4-and-a-half, 5.6-and-1/2, 8-and-a-1/2, etc. Few photographers knew the actual numbers. 1.4-and-a-half is 1.7, 4-and-a-half is 4.8 (four-and-a-third is 4.5), 8-and-a-half is 9.5.

Canon EOS camera set to f/8+1/2
And there you have it--8-and-1/2 (half way between f/8 and f/11) = f/9.5. When spoken out loud you are saying that 8-1/2 equals 9.5. 8-and-1/2 is not the same as 8.5 (which doesn't exist as a specific stop on any cameras that I can think of). Similarly, 11-and-1/2 is 13.5, which is darker than 12.5. Confused? The progression goes 11, 12.5, 13.5 (11-and-1/2), 14, 16. 12.5 and 14 are 1/3 stop increments. 13.5 is a half stop between 11 and 16.

Here are three charts of aperture values:
Full stops:
1.4, 2, 2.8, 4, 5.6, 8, 11, 16, 22, 32

Half stops:
1.7, 2.46, 3.4, 4.8, 6.7, 9.5, 13.5, 19.6, 27

Third stops:
1.6, 1.8, 2.2, 2.5, 3.2, 3.5, 4.5, 5, 6.3, 7, 9, 10, 12.5, 14, 18, 20, 25, 28


In "old timer terms" the progression in half-stops is:
1.4, 1.4+1/2, 2, 2+1/2, 2.8, 2.8+1/2, 4, 4+1/2, 5.6, 5.6+1/2, 8, 8+1/2, 11, 11+1/2, 16, 16+1/2, 22

Newer photographers using electronic cameras (film or digital) might refer to the same progression as:
1.4, 1.7, 2, 2.46, 2.8, 3.4, 4, 4.8, 5.6, 6.7, 8, 9.5, 11, 13.5, 16, 19.6, 22

You need to know which "language" each is speaking in when telling one another to set an aperture on a lens.

Another place this comes into play is in using hand-held meters. My old Minolta Flash Meter III read in 1/10th stops. So, in the same scenario as above, the flash meter might read f/8-and-5/10s which you could read out as f/8+1/2, but which translates to f/9.5. 8-and-7/10s would translate to f/10.

With most cameras now allowing you to set your aperture via a dial on the body instead of on the lens this may seem a bit pedantic. But with the resurgence in interest in film cameras or in modifying lens mounts to allow old lenses to be mounted on a digital camera so you have to set the aperture on the lens itself, it is worth knowing about.

More about aperture numbers in an earlier blog post.


*many older lenses had 1/2 stop indents so that you could set the lens between two full stop settings. And some camera repair shops could modify lenses to have 1/3 stop detents.

Sunday, November 21, 2010

What's with those numbers? Understanding aperture and shutter speed numbers.

1.4, 1.8, 4.0, 5.6, 25 or 6 to 4*... What's with all those numbers on your camera?

Shutter speed is usually easy to define and understand. The progression is logical. 1 second, 1/2 second, 1/4, 1/8, 1/15, 1/30, 1/60, 1/125, 1/250, 1/500, 1/1000, 1/2000, 1/4000, 1/8000. OK, 1/15 and 1/125 aren't exact half/double, but close enough to understand. Each step represents either twice the exposure or half the exposure of the previous number. They are fractions. So 1/2 is larger (longer exposure) than 1/4 or 1/8. Pretty easy to follow.

But it does sometimes get confusing when you get down slower/longer speeds around 1 second. When the shutter speed dial says "2" is that 2 seconds or 1/2 second? On Canon cameras 2 seconds is shown as 2" and 1/2 second is shown as 0"5 (5/10 of a second). 1/4 second is shown as 4, but there is also a 0"4 if you are set to 1/3-stop exposure level increments in your camera's custom functions. If set to 1/3-stop increments you will see 1", 0"8, 0"6, 0"5, 0"4, 0"3, and 4. At 1/2-stop increments you will have 1", 0"7, 0"5, and 0"3, and 4.

Whew! I thought that shutter speed was going to be easier than that. And compared to aperture, it is pretty simple. Now let's look at the standard aperture scale:

1.0, 1.4, 2.0, 2.8, 4.0, 5.6, 8, 11, 16, 22, 32, 45, 64, 90

Looks kind of simple at first. Every other number is double or half. But unlike shutter speed, 2.0 does not give twice the exposure of 4.0. It gives four times the exposure. And what's with 2.0 being greater than 4.0?

Well, apertures are fractions. The full values are 1/1, 1/1.4, 1/2, 1/2.8, 1/4, etc. So that should help understand that 1/2 is larger than 1/4. But what about those numbers in between? 1.4, 2.8, 5.6, etc? Aperture is a measure of area. And these numbers are based on the square root of two (1.4). Each full stop is 1.4x the previous. 1.0 x 1.4 = 1.4, 1.4x1.4 = 1.96(2.0), 2.0 x 1.4 = 2.8, 2.8 x 1.4 = 3.92 (4.0), 4.0 x 1.4 = 5.6, etc. Each step in the full list (above) is one stop more/less than the next number. so 2.0 is twice as much light as 2.8, which is twice as much light as 4.0, which is twice as much light as 5.6.

But, what happens in the lens when you change these numbers? Back in the good old days of film you could open the back of your camera and look through the lens as you changed the aperture and see what happens. For those who haven't seen what changing aperture does, take a look at this illustration:



Here you can see what happens at f/5.6, f/8, f/22, and f/32. I'm hoping that seeing these various apertures, along with knowing that they are fractions, helps understand that "smaller" numbers (1.4, 2.0, 2.8) are larger aperture values (openings) than "larger" numbers (11, 16, 22).

Once you have a good understanding of the progression of shutter speeds and aperture you are well on the way to being able to use your camera without having to stop and think about the numbers. Eventually they should become second nature and not interfere with the process of photography.

The next step is to learn how these numbers affect your photos. Shutter speed affects your ability to stop motion or introduce motion blur. Aperture controls the depth of field (the area between the nearest and furthest objects in the scene that appear to be in focus). But that is for another blog entry.

Please feel free to send questions.

Thanks!


*25 or 6 to 4 isn't photography related. It refers to a song by the band Chicago that is talking about 3:35 or 3:34 (25 or 26 minutes until 4am) in the morning and not being able to sleep. Sometimes these camera numbers keep people awake worrying about them.