Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label education. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 18, 2012

More on perspective

My last post here was about why we might not like what we look at in photographs. And one of my readers, Maximilano da Costa asked a great question. what about taking a photo from 18" with a 100mm lens and then from 60" with the same lens.

Well, the  lens I used here, a Canon 70-200 f/4L, with a Canon 500D closeup lens on it would only focus in as close as 22" so I tried Maximiliano's test at 22" and 60". I hope that is close enough.

Anway, Maximiliano asked if those two images would look the same. I didn't expect that they would. My whole premise is that perspective is determined by camera to subject distance, not by lens.

So, let's take a look at the results...

Camera 22" from the subject's eye
Camera 60" from the subject's eye
I think you can see that the look of the face is quite different between the two. As "promised," the image taken from 60" is much flatter in appearance. Hence looking a little wider/heavier. Here they are side-by-side...

Click to enlarge

Can you see the difference? The image taken at 22 inches has a nice gentle curvature of the cheek as it wraps around from the nose to the ear. The one at 60" is flatter.

This being the internet and all that, I know someone is going to suggest that maybe it is the optics of a zoom lens, even if both images were taken at 100mm. Or someone may suggest that adding the 500D close up filter to allow the 70-200 to focus so close are affecting things. I can assure you they are not.

But in the sense of full testing, I pulled out an old Tamron 90mm macro lens that could focus at 18 inches and repeated the tests. I think you will see the same results...

Camera at 18" from subject's eye
Camera at 60" from subject's eye
 And the side-by-side for closer comparison...

Click to enlarge
Please, don't just take my word for it. What I really want you to do is to go out and try these things yourself. Just because a book says it is so, or some photographer on the net says it is so doesn't mean they are always correct. 

So, go out and take some photos of the same person or mannequin (they tend to hold still longer for a better comparison) and see what happens as you move around them and move closer and further away. And then try a higher or lower camera angle than you usually use. Experiment. These don't have to be images that you show to anyone else. They are references for yourself.  Write your own photography book using the tests you run yourself.

Thank you Maximiliano for asking your question. I love questions. Please post yours in the comments if you have some.

John

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

A Blast From The Fast

In a few past blog posts I've mentioned a TV show I was on in the mid-80s called World of Photography. Unfortunately, I had not been able to find a copy of it to share and I long-ago lent out my VHS copy and never got it back.

WNEW FM Calendar Cover I created and
featured on World of Photography TV

Well, I'm happy to be able to tell you that a number of videos from different photographers, including me, have been uploaded to World of Photography TV's YouTube channel.

You can find my episode, along with some of my favorites from Dean Collins, Al Fisher, Buddy Endress, David M. Kennedy, Jan Cobb, Steve Taylor, Dieter Cohn, Barry Seidman, Walter Wick, Gregory Heisler, Terry Heffernan, Roseanne Rubenstein, Walter Swarthart, and more. Check the channel link above to see all of the videos available.

Check them all out. Most are 7 minutes or less. It is fun to see how much (or maybe how little) has changed in studio photography in the past 25 years.

For me, this feels like the beginning of a long journey that has brought me cross-country from New York to Seattle and into the studios of creativeLIVE where I've presented a couple of workshops and have helped out with many others.

Just hope that no one notices that I'm wearing a tie and no bandana in the video...


Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Fashion Lighting with Matthew Jordan Smith

Wow! What a weekend. I got to assist one of my photography heroes, Matthew Jordan Smith in his 3-day workshop at creativeLIVE.


On Saturday we did some beauty shots with a simple lighting set up of one 22" beauty dish with a white sock diffuse on it directly over the camera. I was so busy, though, that day, that I didn't take any photos.

On Sunday we did a larger set for a fashion session. After that session I got a few comments and questions on Google Plus asking about how the lights were set up for that session. In reality it was pretty simple. A Profoto Magnum reflector on a standard head over the camera about 12 feet up in the air. Matthew described this as his "sun." It was bright. The first meter reading I took was f/45. We had to power that thing down to get to around f/22.


The questions, though, were about our background lights. We had four lights pointed into two v-flats. One v-flat on each side of the set. The v-flats reflected the light onto the background and blocked the light from hitting the models. We used four heads and four strobe packs to get the fastest recycle time we could. If we put all the heads into a single pack it would have taken too long to recylce the power between exposures. With it set up this way Matthew was able to fire off multiple shots in a row to keep things flowing.

To help with the clean white background from head to toe we had the models on a platform created by apple boxes and white boards. Above is a photo of the set and below is a diagram I created to show the lighting setup.


The two softboxes in the photograph are for the video cameras that were broadcasting the workshop and did not affect the still camera exposure. So you can pretend that they are not there.

Here are two photos I took on this set...


And here are photos of the creativeLIVE crew and Matthew and I that were taken with the same lighting setup and a remote camera release (that you can see in my right hand).



This was one of the best weekends I've had. Looking forward to getting myself back into the studio!

The models for this day were Briauna Mariah and Sara Cozad. Styling by Alvin Stillwell, and hair & makeup by Erin Skipley.

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Aspect Ratio


...or why can't I print a full frame image on standard paper sizes

Aspect Ratio is the ratio of the short size of an image to the long side of the image. We talk about it all the time without realizing it. When you get a 4x6 inch print you are describing the aspect ratio of that print: 4x6 (or 2x3, or 1x1.5). The length long side of the image is 1.5 times the length of the short size.

This happens to be the aspect ratio of most digital SLR cameras. These cameras evolved from 35mm film SLR cameras. 35mm film actually measures 24mm x 36mm (do the math, that translates to 2x3 or 1x1.5). Hence a 4x6 print can show the entire frame from a 35mm slide/negative or from most dSLR cameras. I say most because Olympus has SLR cameras with a 3:4 ratio, and most compact digital cameras are also in the 3:4 ratio. But that is not typical for dSLR cameras. I will talk about 3:4 ratio at the end of this post.

So, what happens when you want to make an enlargement from your dSLR image? If you make an 8x12 enlargement you will get the full frame. Everything you originally saw in the image. But, you might be saying, most frames are available in 5x7 or 8x10 sizes. What happens when I make a 5x7 or 8x10 print? What happens is that you either have to crop off parts of the original image, or you have to print with uneven borders (the borders on the long dimension will be wider than those on the short sides. The physical dimensions/aspect ratio of the image and the frame are not the same. Something has to go.

Here is an illustration:


The red line indicates the full 1x1.5 ratio of the dSLR original file. The other lines show the area of the image that will be included in various size prints.
The green lines shows the crop for an 8x10 or 16x20 (1x1.25 aspect ratio). Notice that a relatively large section of the original will be cropped out to make an 8x10 print.
The blue lines show the crop area ofor a 5x7 print (almost the full frame).
The yellow lines show the approximate crop area for an 8.5x11 or 11x14 print.

As mentioned above, there is an alternate way to print. You can have uneven borders, as shown here:


Here you are printing the full image frame (shown by the green lines) on 8x10 paper (red outline) at a size of about 6.67 inches by 10 inches, leaving a wide white border along the long dimensions of the print. I would never deliver a print that showed the uneven borders. I would have it mounted in a mat cut to the appropriate size and shape to display the full frame image and hide those white borders behind the mat.


Here (above) the red frame shows the full image as captured by the camera. The green frame shows the part of the image that can be printed as an 8x10 inch print. Of course that green frame can be moved left or right in the image for the best composition.

Another way to think about this is to divide the long dimension of your original image by the short dimension and then divide the long/short dimension of your frame size and see if they match up. For example, take your original image that is 2:3 ratio. Divide 2 into 3 and you get 1.5. Now take your frame size. First we will try an 8x12 frame. 12 divided by 8 equals 1.5. The number is the same. The original image will scale to 8x12 with no cropping necessary. Second we will try an 8x10 frame. 10 divided by 8 equals 1.25. This does not match the original 1.5, so the image cannot be scaled to 8x10 without cropping.

One more illustration:


Note the black diagonal line from corner to corner of the image. That shows various crops within the image that will maintain the 1:1.5 aspect ratio. The green border and diagonal line indicate the available 8x10 (1:1.25) crops available from this image. Any rectangle who's corners fall on the diagonal green line can be a 8x10 crop from the image.

Here are the some common aspect ratios and print sizes:
Aspect RatioSample Print sizes (no cropping required)
1:1.52x3, 4x6, 8x12, 16x24, 20x30, 32x48
1:1.254x5, 8x10, 16x20, 24x 30, 32x50
1:1.311x14
1:1.45x7

Of course, you can use standard frame sizes and cut custom mats to allow your prints to have a slightly different aspect ratio than the frame. How much different they can be is a personal choice.

3:4 Ratio -- or the 4/3 systemTraditionally, televisions and personal computers have had screens with a 4:3 (width to height) aspect ratio. Computer screens have come in 640x480, 800x600, 1024x768, 1280x960, etc. As compact digital cameras were being developed the 4:3 ratio was adopted by most manufacturers. This way digital camera images fit the computer screens. But they don't fit traditional photographic printing paper sizes.

Here is a 4:3 aspect ratio image with 8x10 (green) and 5x7 (blue) crop guides on it.


The 4:3 aspect ratio translates to 1:33333 and gives you uncropped print sizes like 10.5x14, 9.6x12.8, 
9x12, 7.5x10, or 4.5x6. Not your typical print sizes. But these do work well for online, full-screen presentation.


This is a re-run of an article I originally posted on my web site about 4 years ago.

Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Perspective (again)

I've been seeing some tweets and Facebook messages about how lenses affect perspective and the drawing of the human face. My argument is that the lens doesn't cause the different look, but rather the distance from camera to subject does. The lens focal length just determines the angle of view or what fits into the frame. I could refer you to my previous blog post from this year on this. Or the one before that in 2009. Or even a post from 2007. But no, I'm going to write it all up again for your enjoyment.

I'm not saying that you should photograph everything with a short lens and then crop later to get your composition. But I am saying that you should determine your camera to subject distance to set your perspective and the relationship between items in the photograph and then select the lens focal length that fills the frame appropriately. Don't blame your lens(es) for perspective distortion (expansion or compression of the scene).

Here is a set of 3 images. I'm using a mannequin here instead of human so that there would be no movement between the photographs. One was taken with a 200mm lens, one with a 35mm lens, and one with a 16mm lens. The fourth image takes the 200mm and the 16mm images and combines them in separate layers in Photoshop. I then set the blending mode to "difference" to show how the two images compare. The pixel and noise structure of the two images accounts for the variations inside the facial area. But if you look at the outline of the face, you will see that it is exactly the same in both images. Changing the focal length did not change the perspective. Can you tell which image was taken with which focal length lens?

200mm and 16mm images overlayed
on each other in Photoshop's "Difference"
blending mode. The facial shape and
features are the same.

Here are the full frame originals to show the size differences due to the various lens focal lengths...
200mm lens from 8' away
35mm lens from 8' away
16mm lens from 8' away. Notice that
the relationship between objects
in the scene are the same even with
the widely varied focal lengths used

And to round out the comparison, here are three photos taken with the 200, 35, and 16mm lenses where the camera to subject distance was changed to try to maintain the approximate same size of the face in the frame.

200mm lens from 8' away. Facial features
are flattened. Nose, eyes, and ears are
all similar in size. The face appears slightly
wider than "normal"
35mm lens from about 2' away. Facial
features are more pronounced. The nose
is larger than the ears. The face is
narrower than "normal"
16mm lens from a few inches away.
Facial features are even more distorted.
The nose comes forward, the ears are
much smaller. The face is much narrower
than "normal"

Once again, I'm not suggesting that you take your portraits with a short lens from far away and then crop. I just want to show and help understand that camera to subject distance is what affects the perspective in a photograph. Too often the lens gets blamed for this. Select the appropriate lens for the situation.

Remember, a shorter lens doesn't cause the perspective change. But it does allow you to move in closer so that you get that distortion. And a long lens doesn't compress depth. Blow up the center section and you will find they match (like in the first three images above). Photographs taken with different focal length lenses, but from the same camera position, show exactly the same perspective in the section of the scene that is common to all the different angles of view of the various lenses.

Thanks for putting up with this again!

Saturday, June 4, 2011

Photo Center Northwest Creative Photography Seminar

I've spent the last 10 Wednesday evenings (40 hours) assisting Rosanne Olson in her Creative Seminar class at the Photo Center Northwest. This was a class for advanced students focusing on lighting, portraiture, and still life images.

Rosanne is a great teacher, passionate and dedicated to her students. And the students were all wonderful, too. A win-win situation for all, as my day job employer (Adobe) has a "dollars for doers" program where donates cash to the Photo Center, a 501(c)(3 organization, for every 10 hours I volunteer there.


We started the sessions off with teaching about still life with mixed lighting (strobe, hot lights, daylight). Then moved on to natural light portraits. Then mixed light portraits. We worked both indoors and outdoors (when we could, it seems like there was a major rain storm almost every Wednesday this past spring in Seattle).


In addition to assisting and taking part in the class conversations, I also took a few photos during one class when we had models come in to work with us. Here are some samples. For the studio photos I opted to use the modeling lamps from the strobes instead of the flash so as not to interfere too much with the students.

Mandy
Small softbox, modeling lamp only (no strobe)
Lily
Small softbox, modeling lamp only
Chad
Medium softbox, modeling lamp only
Robert
Medium softbox, modeling lamp only
Chantel
Window light

One of the models returned a couple of weeks later for a session on mixing on-camera flash with evening light. For this photo I had my flash mounted on the camera, but pointed it to my left where Meryl (student in the class) was holding a 2x3' piece of white foam-core to bounce the light onto the subject, Robert. The aim of this class was to use aperture to control the exposure on the subject and shutter speed to control the ambient/background exposure. See an old blog post on mixing strobe and daylight for more info.

Robert
Canon 550ex flash on camera, pointed towards the
left and bounced off a piece of white foam-core
Detail from the above photo where you can see
Meryl holding the foam-core in the catchlight
in Robert's eye. The white dot in the middle
of the eye is the on-camera flash
I'm planning to be back at PCNW this summer for Patricia Ridenour's Form and Figure Class.


All images in this post were taken with a Canon 5DmkII and a Canon 85mm f/1.8 lens.

Sunday, November 21, 2010

What's with those numbers? Understanding aperture and shutter speed numbers.

1.4, 1.8, 4.0, 5.6, 25 or 6 to 4*... What's with all those numbers on your camera?

Shutter speed is usually easy to define and understand. The progression is logical. 1 second, 1/2 second, 1/4, 1/8, 1/15, 1/30, 1/60, 1/125, 1/250, 1/500, 1/1000, 1/2000, 1/4000, 1/8000. OK, 1/15 and 1/125 aren't exact half/double, but close enough to understand. Each step represents either twice the exposure or half the exposure of the previous number. They are fractions. So 1/2 is larger (longer exposure) than 1/4 or 1/8. Pretty easy to follow.

But it does sometimes get confusing when you get down slower/longer speeds around 1 second. When the shutter speed dial says "2" is that 2 seconds or 1/2 second? On Canon cameras 2 seconds is shown as 2" and 1/2 second is shown as 0"5 (5/10 of a second). 1/4 second is shown as 4, but there is also a 0"4 if you are set to 1/3-stop exposure level increments in your camera's custom functions. If set to 1/3-stop increments you will see 1", 0"8, 0"6, 0"5, 0"4, 0"3, and 4. At 1/2-stop increments you will have 1", 0"7, 0"5, and 0"3, and 4.

Whew! I thought that shutter speed was going to be easier than that. And compared to aperture, it is pretty simple. Now let's look at the standard aperture scale:

1.0, 1.4, 2.0, 2.8, 4.0, 5.6, 8, 11, 16, 22, 32, 45, 64, 90

Looks kind of simple at first. Every other number is double or half. But unlike shutter speed, 2.0 does not give twice the exposure of 4.0. It gives four times the exposure. And what's with 2.0 being greater than 4.0?

Well, apertures are fractions. The full values are 1/1, 1/1.4, 1/2, 1/2.8, 1/4, etc. So that should help understand that 1/2 is larger than 1/4. But what about those numbers in between? 1.4, 2.8, 5.6, etc? Aperture is a measure of area. And these numbers are based on the square root of two (1.4). Each full stop is 1.4x the previous. 1.0 x 1.4 = 1.4, 1.4x1.4 = 1.96(2.0), 2.0 x 1.4 = 2.8, 2.8 x 1.4 = 3.92 (4.0), 4.0 x 1.4 = 5.6, etc. Each step in the full list (above) is one stop more/less than the next number. so 2.0 is twice as much light as 2.8, which is twice as much light as 4.0, which is twice as much light as 5.6.

But, what happens in the lens when you change these numbers? Back in the good old days of film you could open the back of your camera and look through the lens as you changed the aperture and see what happens. For those who haven't seen what changing aperture does, take a look at this illustration:



Here you can see what happens at f/5.6, f/8, f/22, and f/32. I'm hoping that seeing these various apertures, along with knowing that they are fractions, helps understand that "smaller" numbers (1.4, 2.0, 2.8) are larger aperture values (openings) than "larger" numbers (11, 16, 22).

Once you have a good understanding of the progression of shutter speeds and aperture you are well on the way to being able to use your camera without having to stop and think about the numbers. Eventually they should become second nature and not interfere with the process of photography.

The next step is to learn how these numbers affect your photos. Shutter speed affects your ability to stop motion or introduce motion blur. Aperture controls the depth of field (the area between the nearest and furthest objects in the scene that appear to be in focus). But that is for another blog entry.

Please feel free to send questions.

Thanks!


*25 or 6 to 4 isn't photography related. It refers to a song by the band Chicago that is talking about 3:35 or 3:34 (25 or 26 minutes until 4am) in the morning and not being able to sleep. Sometimes these camera numbers keep people awake worrying about them.