Showing posts with label flash. Show all posts
Showing posts with label flash. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Flash Modifiers

Most of you who know me know that I try to avoid on camera flash. I actually try to avoid small camera flashes even off-camera. I don't like dealing with batteries, limited modifiers, limited light output, etc.

But there are times that I find I do need to work with a camera flash. So I purchased a couple of diffuser options to test out. One is the often berated Gary Fong diffuser. The other is the newer Rogue FlashBender from ExpoImaging.

The tests were conducted using a Canon 5DmkII with a 50mm f/1.8 lens and a Canon 430EXII flash mounted in the camera's hot shoe. Camera settings were ISO 100, camera in Manual mode at 1/60 at f/1.8. White balance was set to Flash. Flash was in ettl mode at +1/3 stop. The camera is 28 inches from the mannequin and the background is white seamless paper 13 inches behind the mannequin head.

The room I was in is about 12x18 feet with an 8-foot ceiling. Walls and ceiling are painted white. All images are as they came out of the camera into Adobe Lightroom 4.1 with no additional processing.

The FlashBender I used is the Large Reflector along with the Large Diffusion Panel. The Gary Fong I used is the Lightsphere Collapsible with the dome attached (pointed out/convex).

I want to present the results without commentary so you can make your own conclusions. Feel free to note which ones you like in the comments.

Direct flash


Direct flash with bounce card under chin

Ceiling bounce

Ceiling bounce plus fill card under chin

Large FlashBender with diffusion panel

Large FlashBender with diffusion panel with
fill card under chin

Gary Fong Lightsphere pointed up

Lightsphere pointed up with
fill card under chin

Lightsphere pointed towards subject

Lightsphere pointed towards subject with
fill card under chin

Lightsphere pointed towards subject

Lightsphere pointed towards subject
with fill card on side

Lightsphere pointed up

Lightsphere pointed up
with fill card on side

Large FlashBender with diffusion panel

Large FlashBender with diffusion panel
with fill card on side

Direct Flash

Direct Flash with fill card on side

Monday, January 19, 2009

Comparing monolight strobes

I admit it! I have a mixed variety of monolights. I've got a Speedotron Force 10, an Alien Bees Ring Light, and a few SP Systems Excalibur 3200 and 1600 units. I try to not mix them together on the same set to help maintain color fidelity. But I decided to test them all out to find out just how different the color temperature of each is and how consistent the color is when dialing down the power. (Am I the only person out there who wants less strobe power or lower ISO cameras? I would like to have a good ISO 50 or 25 available. Higher ISOs with less noise is OK, but I'm often going in and adding grain.)

Anway, this isn't a scientific test, but I think it will work for my needs. I set up a Greytag Macbeth Color Checker and a WhiBal card at about 5 feet from a light stand. Took a series of photos at full power, 1/2, 1/4 (or -1, -2), etc. with each head. 7" standard reflector on the Excalibur and Speedotron, the 10" ring reflector (no diffuser) on the Alien Bee. I then opened all the files in Adobe Camera Raw 5.2 and used the White Balance tool to read the WhiBal in each image and wrote down the color temp and tint that resulted.

Here are the results:
Power Setting
ColorTemp Adjusted To
Tint Adjusted To
SP Systems Excalibur 3200
Full Power
5150
-4
1/2 Power
5000
-6
1/4 Power
4900
-8
1/8 Power
4900
-8



Alien Bees ABR800 Ring Light
Full Power
5550
-10
1/2 Power
5500
-12
1/4 Power
5400
-12
1/8 Power
5350
-15
1/16 Power
5250
-16
1/32 Power
5200
-19



Speedotron Force 5
Full Power
5350
-8
-1
5250
-8
-2
5250
-7
-3
5150
-10
-4
5100
-12
-5
5050
-15

As you can see, they are all pretty consistent. The color of the light goes slightly bluer (requiring a little bit more yellow compensation in the Color Temperature scale) as the power is lowered. I believe that is to be expected.

I also metered all three heads in the same configuration at 5 feet at full / minimum power:

Excalibur: 22 / 8
Alien Bee Ring Light: 32 / 5.6
Speedotron Force 5: 32 / 5.6

I won't list the watt-second ratings, as I don't think that number matters much, especially when comparing different brands of strobe heads. Watt-seconds measures how much energy can be stored in the capacitor. It doesn't really tell us much about the efficiency of the system.

Bottom line, I'm happy with all of these products.

Tuesday, May 8, 2007

Outdoor Fill Flash

How to mix strobe with sunlight

There are two basic concepts to keep in mind---
* The flash/strobe exposure is controlled by the aperture
* The ambient light exposure is controlled by the shutter speed
You are creating a double-exposure in one frame from two light sources.

The first think you need to know is the highest flash sync shutter speed for your camera. This is typically between 1/125 and 1/250 of a second, but varies by camera and could be higher or lower. This information is in your camera manual.

Start by metering the scene using the shutter speed about two stops lower than the max sync speed. For example., if your camera can sync at up to 1/250 of a second start the process by metering at 1/60 of a second (two stops lower than 1/250). Note the aperture required at that shutter speed. For example, let's say the meter said F/8 at 1/60.

Meter the flash/strobe with a hand-held flash meter. If the meter has a shutter speed setting set it to the max sync speed for your camera. For this example, let's say that the flash meter reads F/11.

Adjust the output of the flash to get a reading that matches the ambient light reading from the previous step. In this case we would lower the power of the flash 1 stop so that the meter reads F/8. If you cannot lower the flash power you will need to move the flash further away from the subject or add some diffusion material or neutral density filters over the flash to lower the output.

Set your camera (in Manual mode) to F/8 and 1/125. The scene should be balanced between the ambient and flash.

Now you can adjust your shutter speed for effect. A faster shutter speed will darken the background without making the flash-lit subject darker. But keep in mind that you can't set a shutter speed higher than your flash sync speed. A slower shutter speed will start to overexpose/wash out the background (make it brighter than the subject) But if you go too far you may also end up brightening the subject, too. And you also risk having some motion blur and ghosting around the subject (which is not necessarily bad, it can be an interesting effect).

But what happens if your flash exposure is F/22 but you want to photograph at F/8 or F/11? You have to lower the output of your flash unit. This can be done by lowering the power on the strobe. If you cannot lower it any more you can try moving the lights back (not good if you are trying to keep the light close and soft, moving them back may give too much contrast), or you can change the light quality by adding more diffusion, or you can use neutral density filters over the flash.

Another option is to use a Neutral Density (ND) filter on the camera. With a 3-stop ND filter your flash exposure will go from F/22 to F/8. Meter again for the ambient light with the ND filter in place to determine your balancing shutter speed. If you are using a hand-held meter for the ambient light remember to adjust it to take into account the ND filter. Again, you can adjust the shutter speed up/down to affect the look of the background (remember it has to be lower than the max sync speed of your camera).

Example:

Flash exposure f/22
Ambient exposure 1/60 @ F/22 (or 1/500 @ F/8)
Desired aperture F/8

Use a 3-stop neutral density filter:
Flash exposure F/8
Ambient Exposure 1/60 @ F/8